Most people come to this topic after a slightly unsettling conversation. You have found the unit you want, the agent has sent the draft lease, and buried somewhere in the middle is a clause requiring you to pay the landlord's buildings insurance. It feels unfair on a quick read, and it is easy to assume you have been handed something unusual. In truth, it is completely standard, and understanding why it exists will save you money and stress.
I have reviewed hundreds of commercial leases over the years, and the insurance clauses are consistently the ones tenants read fastest and worry about least. That is a mistake. Buildings insurance sits alongside your repairing obligations and service charge, and the three of them together often decide whether a bad year becomes an unaffordable one. Below I have set out how landlord buildings insurance typically works in England and Wales, where the genuine risks lie, and the questions worth asking before you put pen to paper.
If you are new to business tenancies, it may help to start with our guide to how a commercial lease works and then return here, because the insurance provisions only make sense once you understand the broader structure.
How does landlord buildings insurance work in a commercial lease?
Landlord buildings insurance in a commercial lease commonly works by the landlord arranging insurance for the building and recovering the appropriate cost from the tenant as insurance rent. The policy protects the physical property against specified risks, while the tenant normally remains responsible for insuring its own stock, equipment, contents and business-related risks.
This structure is common because the landlord owns the investment and wants control over whether the building is properly insured.
The RICS Code for Leasing Business Premises reflects the market norm that the landlord will typically secure and initially pay for the insurance cover and then recharge the tenant. In multi-let properties, the landlord normally insures the whole building and tenants contribute their appropriate proportions.
However, the lease is the crucial document. Do not assume every commercial property follows exactly the same arrangement, because they do not.
In practice
In one recent matter, a tenant had budgeted for rent and service charge but had not factored in the insurance rent at all. The insurance contribution added roughly eight per cent to the annual cost of occupation. It was recoverable under the lease, it was perfectly lawful, and it caught them by surprise.
Who normally arranges buildings insurance for commercial premises?
The landlord normally arranges buildings insurance, particularly where a tenant occupies only part of a larger property. For a whole-building lease, the landlord also commonly retains control of the insurance. In some circumstances, however, the lease may make the tenant responsible for arranging appropriate buildings insurance itself.
Where premises form only part of a building, it simply is not practical for each tenant to arrange cover for the structure. The landlord insures the whole building instead, and that approach keeps the position clean.
Even where an entire building is let, the landlord will usually still want to control the insurance. This helps avoid:
- Gaps in insurance
- Inconsistent cover between tenants
- Insufficient rebuilding cover
- Multiple policies covering the same structure
- Problems controlling a major insurance claim
Where tenant-arranged cover does occur, it is usually in a whole-building lease granted to a strong covenant, and even then it is often balanced with an obligation to insure for full reinstatement value and to name the landlord as an interested party. For a deeper look at how the repair and insurance obligations interact, our overview of full repairing and insuring obligations is a useful companion to this article.
Who pays for buildings insurance in a commercial lease?
Although the landlord commonly arranges the policy, the commercial tenant will often bear some or all of the cost. The lease may require the tenant to reimburse the landlord through a separate insurance rent or another contractual payment. In multi-let buildings, the premium is commonly apportioned between the different tenants.
Take a simple example:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Annual buildings insurance premium | £12,000 |
| Tenant's agreed share of the building | 25% |
| Annual insurance rent payable | £3,000 |
But the method of apportionment should always be checked. It might depend on:
- Floor area
- Rateable value
- A stated percentage
- The landlord's reasonable assessment
- Another formula specified in the lease
RICS guidance recommends that the parties establish at Heads of Terms stage who will arrange the insurance and who will bear its cost. That single conversation often prevents a dispute later. Our team regularly advises at that stage through our Heads of Terms service, where insurance costs and apportionment are pinned down early.